Cream Of Mushroom Soup vs Beef Broth

CheckTag rates them about the same (2.5 and 2.5 out of 5). The differences are in the details below.

Side by side

Cream Of Mushroom SoupBeef Broth
CheckTag rating2.5/52.5/5
Shopper reviewsNo reviews yetNo reviews yet
Flagged ingredients95✓
Ingredients listed1315
Allergens——
Net quantity——
Safety noteYesYes

Ingredients worth a second look

Cream Of Mushroom Soup
  • Vegetable Oil (corn, canola, soybean) (Fats/Emulsifier) — Contributes to creamy texture; blend of refined vegetable oils high in omega-6 fatty acids potentially promoting inflammation when consumed excessively.
  • Modified Cornstarch (Thickener/Stabilizer) — Used to create desired consistency; processed carbohydrate with high glycemic impact and little to no nutritional benefit.
  • Wheat Flour (Thickener) — Assists with thickening the soup; contains gluten, a common allergen that can cause digestive issues or autoimmune responses in sensitive individuals.
  • Salt (Flavor Enhancer) — Boosts taste but significantly contributes to high sodium levels, which may lead to elevated blood pressure and increased cardiovascular risk.
  • Cream (Dairy Component) — Provides creaminess and some vitamins; contains saturated fats and is a dairy allergen which may trigger reactions in those with milk allergies or lactose intolerance.
  • Whey (Dairy By-product) — Adds protein and texture; derived from milk making it an allergen and potential source of lactose causing gastrointestinal distress for some consumers.
  • Soy Protein Concentrate (Protein Additive) — Increases protein content marginally; soy is a top allergen and the concentrate may be from GMO sources with debated long-term health effects.
  • Monosodium Glutamate (Flavor Enhancer) — Intensifies savory flavors; can cause adverse reactions like headaches in MSG-sensitive people and remains controversial despite regulatory approval.
  • Yeast Extract (Flavor Enhancer) — Natural umami booster often used as MSG alternative; still contains free glutamates that may affect sensitive individuals similarly.
Beef Broth
  • Salt (Flavor Enhancer/Preservative) — Boosts taste but significantly raises sodium levels, increasing risks for high blood pressure, fluid retention and cardiovascular issues with frequent use.
  • Sugar (Sweetener/Flavor Balancer) — Added refined sugar contributes to overall glycemic load and empty calories; caution for blood sugar management and weight control even in small percentages.
  • Yeast Extract (Umami/Flavor Enhancer) — Delivers savory depth and trace B-vitamins but may cause headaches or reactions in those sensitive to glutamates similar to MSG effects.
  • Dextrose (Sweetener/Flavor) — Highly refined glucose that can spike blood sugar rapidly; caution as an added sugar with no mitigating fiber or nutrients.
  • Honey (Natural Sweetener) — Provides mild sweetness with trace antioxidants but acts as added sugar contributing to total intake without substantial benefits at low levels.

What's different inside

They share 2 ingredients.

Only in Cream Of Mushroom Soup

Water (Base), Mushrooms (Main Ingredient), Vegetable Oil (corn, canola, soybean) (Fats/Emulsifier), Modified Cornstarch (Thickener/Stabilizer), Wheat Flour (Thickener), Cream (Dairy Component), Whey (Dairy By-product), Soy Protein Concentrate (Protein Additive), Monosodium Glutamate (Flavor Enhancer), Dried Garlic (Seasoning), Natural Flavoring (Flavor Additive)

In both

Salt (Flavor Enhancer), Yeast Extract (Flavor Enhancer)

Only in Beef Broth

Beef Stock (Base/Broth), Sugar (Sweetener/Flavor Balancer), Natural Flavor (Flavoring Agent), Onion Juice (Vegetable Flavoring), Beef Fat (Fat/Flavor Carrier), Tomato Paste (Concentrate/Flavoring), Dextrose (Sweetener/Flavor), Beef Extract (Concentrated Flavor), Honey (Natural Sweetener), Carrot Puree (Vegetable Puree/Flavor), Potato Flour (Thickener/Starch), Celery Puree (Vegetable Puree/Flavor), Onion Powder (Dried Seasoning)

More comparisons

Scan before you buy

CheckTag shows what's inside any product, how it rates, and what other shoppers say. Free on iPhone and Android, or right inside Telegram and WhatsApp.

Ratings and ingredient notes are generated by AI from the product's available data — a guide, not a diagnosis. Always check the product's own label, and follow your doctor or pharmacist for medicines.